My buddy who is also a science teacher and a devout fundamentalist christian will laugh when he sees my title to this blog. I am the non-churchgoing social relativist. It is he that should have this title (but he would think it blasphemous and not use it anyway). But, as science teachers, we are apostles in way. Not in the sense of spreading faith, but indeed we do try and spread good news. Our good news is that we have logic and and a philosophy of thought (the scientific method) that anyone can learn and use.
My friend is always complaining of science teachers who try to use science education to dismiss spirituality and faith. He says that really they are just substituting their scientific beliefs for religion and trying to gain converts just as a major religion would. I think this is a bit harsh on us poor agnostic non churchgoers who don't quite have it all figured out yet like he has. But what he really means is that when you teach science if you get bogged down in the just facts and data you start to teach the principles as facts as well rather than using the data and facts to lead the student to the truth of the great principles and concepts of how the world works. Sometimes in the rush to make it through a curriculum we forget to present data as the clues that lead us to the grand theory. Also we sometimes forget to mention that there is quite a bit that still needs to be discovered and figured out. So by teaching science as a process (and an unfinished one at that), we are not using it to replace beliefs but as a tool for understanding.
In this science education is unique and always fascinating. First: keeping in mind that we don't know everything. I love it when a student can find an example or exception to a rule that proves the point or reveals a possible deeper mystery. Second: unlike many subjects in the humanities, there are some cold, hard indisputable facts and answers so students have to learn to use analysis and logic not just flowery prose to make a point. And, most importantly, the benefits of good science are all around us, so that it is easy to show students that learning to think like a scientist can make a difference.
So in reality we are apostles spreading the good news of a thought process that has changed our world (mostly for the better) and will change it again. Our students either will hear us and use the process of scientific thought with their beliefs to make reasoned choices about how science will shape the world or ignore it and allow others to make decisions for them.
Sunday, February 1, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi Jay,
ReplyDeleteIt sounds like you are a fortunate person who has found a vocation (sorry for the lame religious reference) ... I'm sure your students are inspired by your passion for science.